Skip to content
FairRips
Rubric version 1.0

How we grade

We ask every app the same 3 questions. We write down plain facts, like where the odds are shown. A fixed formula turns those facts into 0 to 3 points for each check. We add up the points to get a letter grade.

The same facts always give the same grade. No one picks a grade by feel.

Try it

Pick the facts. Watch the grade.

This is the real formula. Change any fact and see the points change.

Odds

1. Odds

3 of 3 points

Where does the app show the odds?

Where the odds are
How the odds are written
Buyback

2. Buyback

2 of 3 points

What does the app pay to buy a card back?

Is there a buyback?
Time to decide
Paid in
Limits

3. Limits

2 of 3 points

Can you cap your own spending?

Spending cap
A higher cap starts
Your result7 of 9 pointsMostly fair, with one or two weak spots.
  • OddsThe odds are on every pack page before you pay. That earns 3 points.
  • BuybackA buyback of 80 percent earns 2 points.
  • LimitsYou can set a cap yourself, but a higher cap starts right away. That earns 2 points.

What would raise it

Pay at least 85 percent of a card's stated value. That would raise the grade from B to A.

This runs the same formula we use for every real grade. It is a tool to explore, not a grade for any app.

The 3 checks

Odds

Are the chances shown before you pay?

You should know what you can get before you spend money. If the chances are hidden, you cannot tell if a pack is worth it.

Facts we write down

  • Where are the odds? We look on each pack page, the checkout page, and the help pages.
  • Are the odds real numbers, like 2 percent? Or only words, like rare?

How the facts become points

  • Not shown anywhere: 0 points.
  • Only in fine print, on a help page, or after you pay: 1 point.
  • On the page for some packs, before you pay: 2 points.
  • On the page for every pack, before you pay: 3 points.
  • If the odds are only words, like rare, and not numbers, the most you can get is 2 points.
What each score means
PointsMeaning
3Shown. Real numbers for the chances are shown before you pay, on every pack.
2Partly shown. The chances are shown before you pay, but only for some packs, or only in words like rare.
1Hard to find. The chances are only in fine print, on a help page, or after you pay.
0Hidden. We could not find the chances anywhere.

Buyback

If you sell a card back, how much of its stated value do you get? How long do you have to decide?

Many apps offer to buy your card back. A fair buyback pays you a good share of what the app says the card is worth. It also gives you time to decide.

Facts we write down

  • Is there a buyback at all?
  • What percent of the card's stated value does it pay?
  • How many days do you have to decide?
  • Does it pay real money, or only credit you can spend in the app?

How the facts become points

  • No buyback, or less than 50 percent: 0 points.
  • 50 to 69 percent: 1 point.
  • 70 to 84 percent: 2 points.
  • 85 percent or more: 3 points.
  • If you have less than 7 days to decide, the most you can get is 2 points.
  • If you must decide right when the pack opens, you lose 1 more point.
  • If the buyback pays only in app credit, you lose 1 point.
What each score means
PointsMeaning
3Strong. The buyback pays at least 85 percent in real money, and you have at least 7 days.
2Fair. The buyback pays a fair share, but has a short time limit or pays only in credit.
1Low. The buyback pays a low share, or has strict rules.
0Poor. There is no buyback, or it pays very little once the rules are counted.

Limits

Can you set a cap on your own spending?

A spending cap helps you stick to your budget. The best apps make it easy to set one and slow to raise it.

Facts we write down

  • Can you set a spending cap yourself in the app?
  • If not, can support set one for you?
  • If you raise your cap, how long until the new cap starts?

How the facts become points

  • No way to set a cap: 0 points.
  • Only by asking support: 1 point.
  • You can set a cap yourself in the app: 2 points.
  • You can set it yourself, and raising it takes at least 24 hours to start: 3 points.
What each score means
PointsMeaning
3Yes. You can set a cap yourself, and a higher cap waits at least 24 hours to start.
2Yes, basic. You can set a cap yourself, but a higher cap starts right away.
1Ask support. You can only get a cap by asking support.
0No. There is no way to set a spending cap.

From points to a letter

The most points an app can get is 9. Here is how the total turns into a grade.

  • 8 to 9 pointsFair on all 3 checks.
  • 6 to 7 pointsMostly fair, with one or two weak spots.
  • 4 to 5 pointsSome good parts, some real problems.
  • 2 to 3 pointsBig problems on most checks.
  • 0 to 1 pointsFails almost every check.

Only apps with an A get the FairRips Certified badge.

Our rules for grading

  • If an app gets 0 points on any check, the best grade it can get is a C. A fair app cannot fail a check all the way.
  • We only post a grade when we have dated proof for every fact.
  • If we have not checked an app in 120 days, its report says the grade may be out of date.
  • Every app gets the same 3 checks. No app gets a special deal.
  • We save proof for each fact, like a screenshot or a link, and we write down the date.
  • If we have not checked all 3 things yet, the app says "Grade coming soon". We never guess.
  • Each report says what the app could change to get a better grade.
  • Sponsors are graded the same way as everyone else. Paying us never changes a grade.

Words we use

  • Stated value is what the app says a card is worth. We use the app's own number.
  • Fine print means the odds are only in the terms or on a help page. They are not on the pack page or the checkout page.
  • Real numbers means odds like "2 percent" or "1 in 50". Words like "rare" or "super rare" do not count.
  • App credit is money you can only spend inside the app, like on more packs.

If we change these rules, we will say so here. Then we will check every app again.